RutlandHerald.com - We Are Vermont

The article requested can not be found! Please refresh your browser or go back. (RH,20081111,THISJUSTIN,811110289,AR).






READER COMMENTS


Context is lost when one or two quotes are taken from an hour long interview, TNC's position on lampricide use was not fully represented in this article. I can assure Mr. Parker and others that TNC does not support indiscriminate use of this chemical, in fact we invest considerable effort towards exactly opposite outcome. We are very concerned about the acute and chronic impacts of lampricide treatment on other fish, amphibians and invertebrates such as mussels. We helped delay treatment of the Poultney River for a number of years and advocated for lowest possible pesticide concentrations when it was finally treated. We have pushed management agencies to acknowledge that sea lamprey is native species, and have developed research proposals aimed at restoring ecosystem level checks on sea lamprey abundance, as an alternative to chemical treatment. We lead field work aimed specifically at measuring the impact of lampricides on non-target species.

It is accurate to say that we support the control program, to the extent that we understand sea lamprey populations to be out of balance and harmful not only to game fish populations but other species such as sturgeon and whitefish. And we are actively involved in the control program as advocates for ecosystem based alternatives to lampricides, and very conservative use of chemicals when they are applied at all.

Tom Berry - TNC
-- Posted by Tom Berry on Fri, Nov 14, 2008, 12:14 pm EST

report this comment



Kudos to those questioning the indiscriminate, abusive and irresponsible use of pesticides in our waters. Like other pisicides of similarly common but equally irresponsible and widespread use by our government and TNC, TFM has been shown to have devastating effects on both the macroinvertebrate and amphibian communities where it has been used. Moreover, both TFM and its metabolites have been shown to be highly carcinogenic and to pose potentially serious threats to human health. Yet, TNC advocates the continuing, widespread and indiscriminate use of this poison in the absence of factual support or long-term result. Apparently, TNC, along with its federal partners, are now also advocates of the destruction of macroinvertebrate and amphibian biodiversity. Is the potential for fewer lampreys (as yet unrealized after more than 20 years of use) worth these additive and as yet unquantified losses of biodiversity and the equally unquantified but potentially serious risks to human health that continuing use of this poison presents? I don't think so, and I doubt anyone else (other than TNC and its govt. buddies) would either after checking what this stuff is and actually does at www.fluroridealert.org/pesticides/tfm.pubmed.abstracts.htm. Finally, because of the risks to the environment, biodiversity, and the human community that use of TFM poses, an EIS -- not a mere EA -- is required under NEPA for each of these poisoning projects.
-- Posted by Dennis Parker on Wed, Nov 12, 2008, 3:14 pm EST

report this comment



SIMPLE COST-EFFECTIVE SOLUTION:
Constitution of the State of Vermont, General Provisions Section 64:
The criminal shall be employed for the benefit of the public.

O.K., now unlock the cages where convicted Vermonters and innocent pre-trial detainees who can't afford bail are treated like animals worse than in a zoo, and put the actual convicted prisoners out on Lake Champlain in rowboats
and have them fish the Sea Lamprey out, and weed out the milfoil,
and sell it at a high price to gardeners in Beverly Hills, California
over the internet.

Toxic chemicals may be lowering Vermont mens' sperm count and causing health problems. Demand a Material Safety Data Hazard Sheet before you believe
chemical industry stories about "safe" chemicals.

Cris Ericson, Vote for me in 2010 if you want to stop being abused by chemicals and other abuse going on in this state! http://crisericson.com
-- Posted by Cris Ericson on Tue, Nov 11, 2008, 6:02 pm EST

report this comment


You must be logged in to leave a comment. Register | Log In

Logout

The article requested can not be found! Please refresh your browser or go back. (RH,20081111,THISJUSTIN,811110289,AR). The article requested can not be found! Please refresh your browser or go back. (RH,20081111,THISJUSTIN,811110289,AR).