RutlandHerald.com - We Are Vermont

'Sexting' suspect in court next month



Toolbox

By Brent Curtis Staff Writer - Published: June 5, 2009

A 16-year-old Rutland boy who allegedly sent indecent photos of himself via cell phone to a 14-year-old girl will be arraigned on a criminal charge in Rutland District Court next month.

News of the charge was released just days after Gov. James Douglas signed a new law that provides prosecutors discretion to divert "sexting" cases from the criminal docket to the juvenile courts.

"I'm curious myself to see how it will be handled," said city Detective Michael Notte, who investigated the case.

At the moment, the 16-year-old, whom Notte declined to name because of his age, faces a misdemeanor charge of disseminating indecent material to a minor outside the presence of the minor — an offense that carries a penalty of up to a year in jail.

But it's possible that even though the alleged offense was committed prior to the new law's effective date July 1, the teenaged boy may be eligible for diversion to the juvenile system since his arraignment date isn't until later next month.

"If it was a year from this, this sort of case would be exactly the type of case the law was looking at," Rep. Margaret Flory, a member of the House Judiciary Committee, said Thursday. "But given the offense date and the effective date of the law, I don't know if it could be applied in this case."

Notte said the sexting case involved two teenagers who had dated in the past. However, he said, the indecent images sent to the girl were unsolicited and unwelcome.

"I think it was supposed to be more or less out of fun," Notte said of the teenage boy's motives. "I don't think these kids think about the consequences of their actions. Beyond any legal consequences, these images can be devastating if they end up on the Internet."

Rutland County prosecutors, who have been involved in judicial training all week, couldn't be reached on Thursday.

But Flory said even if Notte's case were eligible for diversion to the juvenile system, she wasn't sure prosecutors would choose to drop the criminal complaint.

"Generally, if there's no relationship between the two people involved in these cases, it's a different case — that's why we wanted to give prosecutors the discretion to decide," Flory said. "To me, it's more bothersome that someone could send something unsolicited to someone that they're not even in a relationship with."

brent.curtis@rutlandherald.com








READER COMMENTS


Sexting. I do not condone it.
Not a good idea. Prosecute the offender (under the age of 18) and impose a hefty fine and order community work of some duration.
The 14 year old girl will get over it, in no time. A 14 year old girl is caught in bed with a twenty-something year old male having sex. Police was called and they
"investigated" the complaint. Nothing was done; no charges were filed against the male adult.
That being so; let's go after the real serious law breakers; such as bankers, lawyers, dope dealers and politicians.
Does that make some sence?? Anyone??

Sven Moller, Rutland.
-- Posted by Sven Moller on Sun, Jun 7, 2009, 10:57 am EST

report this comment



Cell phones are becoming a tool for many to control and harass others. If this boy showed up on the front porch of this girl's home and exposed himself in the same way instead of over the phone would we feel differently? It's the same action just a different mechanism. Much of the question lies in how the girl felt about the advances and if he desisted after any comments about them being unwelcome.
-- Posted by none none on Sat, Jun 6, 2009, 5:24 pm EST

report this comment



He is a 16 year old kid that did a stupid thing. That's what 16 year olds do. We have a law that treats him as a child then punishes him as if he were an adult. To charge him as adult is insane. Yes, what he did was wrong but we should not ruin his life for this. Our lawmakers changed the laws to correct this. I hope common sense prevails and this childs life will not be ruined.
-- Posted by Billky None on Fri, Jun 5, 2009, 6:35 pm EST

report this comment



But just what is "indecent" a 16 year old sending a nude picture of himself? Oh my!! Did he have a hard on?? A "***" shot"? Aren't we all panting in a voyeuristic frenzy to know!!

"Any picture, photograph, drawing, sculpture, motion picture film, or similar visual representation or image, including any such representation or image which is stored electronically, of a person or portion of the human body which depicts nudity, sexual conduct or sado-masochistic abuse AND which is harmful to minors..." Title 13 Vermont Statutes Annotated Sect. 2802
.
.
-- Posted by David Searles on Fri, Jun 5, 2009, 5:35 pm EST

report this comment



at what point do you hold people responsible for their actions? Send the 16 year old to jail for a year, absolutely the correct thing to do. But in the case of none none, i guess a slap on the wrist would be more in order, and hope the 16 year old doesn't turn into a sexual deviant or molest some one else, maybe one of your kids, or the neighbor kids or some other relative. Teach them a lesson now, before it is to late.
-- Posted by m e on Fri, Jun 5, 2009, 1:38 pm EST

report this comment



Okay- at 16 years old this young man is not a child. He should know better. I guess it could be considered a mistake if he just happened to have his phone in the shower with him and it "accidently" took a pix of his junk. Oh yeah, that must have been it. He slipped on the soap and fell on the "capture image" button. You're probably right None None. Try to remember it's an innocent mistake when some idiot sends nasty pix of himself to you or your 14 year old daughter. ...But then again you probably don't have kids if you can be this ignorant. Or maybe the 16 yr old is your son...
-- Posted by Somebody New on Fri, Jun 5, 2009, 8:53 am EST

report this comment



wow lets threaten to send a child to prison for making a mistake...
-- Posted by None None on Fri, Jun 5, 2009, 7:54 am EST

report this comment


You must be logged in to leave a comment. Register | Log In

Logout