RutlandHerald.com - We Are Vermont

Downtown Santa no more

Rutland Post Office restricts mailman from wearing Santa suit



U.S. Postal employee Kelly Socia (right) drops mail off to Peter Puotinen at Aubuchon Hardware on West Street in Rutland in a prior year. Socia was restricted by the Rutland Post Office from wearing his Santa suit this year.

Albert J. Marro / Rutland Herald

Toolbox

By Cristina Kumka STAFF WRITER - Published: December 12, 2009

Veteran mailman Kelly Socia doesn't get it. Why would the Rutland Post Office, after 10 years of giving him permission to wear a Santa suit during his downtown mail deliveries in the days leading up to Christmas, adamantly say no this year?

"Last year they told me I couldn't wear it because it was offensive to some people," Socia said downtown during his lunch break Thursday.

"Is it a uniform issue or a political correctness issue?"

Socia, the 55-year-old owner of Vermont Backroad Tours and a mail carrier for 29 years in Rutland, Proctor and Poultney, said he never received more than a smile and wave as Santa during his routes over the last 25 years and said he wasn't given a good reason why he couldn't don the red and white holiday symbol again.

Socia said he didn't wear the suit last year, but not because he was forced not to.

Socia said he plans to ask for a written response from the post office as to why. He also said if his bosses ask him to take further steps, like forcing him to remove his candy-striped and holiday ties, he plans to file a grievance citing past practice.

Socia aired his concern on the Dennis Miller radio show Wednesday.

In response, Miller said, "We're in the no-fun zone now and that's how it works."

Rutland Postmaster Sal Vitagliano said Thursday he didn't know what Socia was talking about.

He called all post office uniform policies "internal matters."

"He (Socia) hasn't discussed it with me at all," Vitagliano said.

On Friday, Socia said he was given a direct order from Vitagliano that he couldn't wear the suit.

Vitagliano and Steve Downs, the supervisor of all mail carriers, did not respond to repeated calls for comment Friday.

Thomas Rizzo, spokesman for United States Postal Service, said mail carriers are required to wear official uniforms and there are reasons why.

"First and foremost, the public recognizes those in uniform are official United States Postal Service employees, are on official business and can trust him or her as representing the organization that has served the country for 234 years," Rizzo wrote in an e-mail.

"Aside from being recognizable and reassuring, official postal uniforms are constructed to be visible with reflective material which promotes the letter carrier's personal safety in a variety of weather, lighting and road conditions."

And, wearing official USPS uniforms was agreed upon by the mail carriers' union, the National Association of Letter Carriers, and is contained in their contract, according to Rizzo.

Although Santa outfits are allowed at times, "they are done under very limited circumstances, primarily on Christmas Day for Express Mail package deliveries and are announced to the public ahead of time," Rizzo wrote.

Downtown merchants had mixed reactions to Socia not wearing his trademark suit this year.

"I thought it was always cute," said Ivan Rochon, co-owner of Desjardins Rochon Jewelers on Center Street.

Jim McNeil of McNeil & Reedy, a men's formal wear shop on Merchants Row, said there's good reason why the post office would restrict a carrier from wearing a Santa suit but there may be other reasons too.

"He should've been aware of the federal policy to begin with," McNeil said.

"Killington employees wear Killington jackets."

Longtime McNeil & Reedy employee Julie Loyzelle said her son works for United Parcel Service and if he was out of uniform, he would be sent home.

Loyzelle said times have changed and people may not trust a Santa coming to their door, even if he does have mail in his hand.

"He could be there to rob you," she said.

McNeil said, "He might not be, but somebody else who may follow suit may be."

Socia claims he always wore the suit just for fun and in his experience, no one minded.

"The thing is, when I wore that suit, people were always laughing, smiling … honking and giving me the thumbs up," Socia said.

"St. Nicholas is one thing, but Santa Claus is secular."

cristina.kumka@rutlandherald.com








READER COMMENTS


After some of these guys finish kicking the shiet out of that religious icon Santa, Ill bet they roast the Easter bunny on a spit come April.
-- Posted by None None on Mon, Dec 14, 2009, 4:02 pm EST

report this comment



How often has anyone seen the Postmaster in Rutland City wear the USPO uniform issue? Or any other Postmaster come to think of it. Fear of recognition? Substandard to their status? If the house rule says wear the identity; then apply it to everyone!
-- Posted by Ed Larson on Mon, Dec 14, 2009, 12:02 pm EST

report this comment



That was kind of a "Bad Santa" anyway I think.
-- Posted by Steve Little on Mon, Dec 14, 2009, 6:56 am EST

report this comment



Is it about a dress code or the complaint of someone new on the block,Mr. Vitagliano set a precedent for 10 years by allowing Mr. Socia to wear the santa suit. Mr. Vitagliano stated that all uniform policies are an internial thing,so maybe it came from the higher-ups in the ****** service.If its the policy maybe Mr Socia should just wear his ****** uniform and work on the santa thing over the next year to try and bring the santa suit back. I do think Christmas has become very commercialized and about the money these corporations can make.I was raised to believe it's the thought behind the gift not the gift its self. I to like to see all the decorations and trees lit,school plays,hear Christmas songs,religious or not. It seems to be a few that say they are offended and the rest of us have to change our ways and beliefs to suit them ,Like Merry Christmas to Happy Holiday.I say the hell with being politically correct. I would like to wish all a safe Merry Christmas and Happy New Year.
-- Posted by Born in Vermont on Sun, Dec 13, 2009, 9:01 pm EST

report this comment



Santa is not a religious character. He is not of the Christian mythologies, but rather added to the holiday later. He is tied to a religious holiday but in itself is not a religious figure. There should be no problem allowing a postman to dress like him.
-- Posted by Scott Frank on Sun, Dec 13, 2009, 6:36 pm EST

report this comment



Lives in Colorado, my t-shirt suggestion was done in jest. Obviously it would not be an actual product- I was trying to lighten up the board. Wow, what a sourpuss!

When our schools fail to provide fun for our children in terms of Christmas joy, parents just need to step up to the plate. We've made paper chains, cookies, gingerbread houses, cutouts- things that used to be done at school and are fun for kids to do. At Sunday School, they have done terrific music and crafts while learning about Christ in a positive and fun manner. Public schools, when they don't provide the things children and parents need, will continue to view declining enrollments. And not just because there are fewer children born, but because more people are homeschooling, sending to private schools, or boarding schools. At some point in the near future, I am sure that budgets will stop being passed because voters will say" Hmm, they don';t do what I want, so I am not going to vote for it" End of story. And whether its about curriculum, the way a holiday is celebrated, or the condition of the school, in the end, the voters have the power.

Schools should do as much to make individuals welcome as possible; inviting them to events, sharing dinners with people, student performances.
-- Posted by Colleen Wright on Sun, Dec 13, 2009, 7:47 am EST

report this comment



The war against Christmas, Christians and Jesus continues.

How sad that post office managers and school boards have nothing between their legs. "Santa" doesn't offend anyone. There's always someone looking to be offended so they can get attention. Wimps......
-- Posted by None None on Sun, Dec 13, 2009, 7:23 am EST

report this comment



Well maybe if we didn't all just shut up, put our tail between our legs and cooperate, we would still have the spirit.

Stand up sand say something, ask where the spirit is at the concerts, I mean stand up in the crowd and ask the audience how many prefer Christmas over Indian? Ask where the Christmas decorations are and then ask where the spirit of Christmas and the meaning of Christmas went?
we need to start with ourselves and bring the spirit back.

MERRY CHRISTMAS, even to you, Notta, Comfy, That Guy and all the rest of you Liberals, Merry Christmas and have a Joyous Holiday Season with your loved ones.
-- Posted by Name Change on Sun, Dec 13, 2009, 7:01 am EST

report this comment



I lived in Poultney & North Poultney most of my live never did I see the postman wear a uniform. He all was had street clothes. He came to the door if we had packages the didn't fix in the box. He was very nice to everyone...................... But the Rule should be good for some & not all of the USPS workers.
-- Posted by joy joy on Sun, Dec 13, 2009, 1:26 am EST

report this comment



These type of shenanigans happened last year in a smaller town's school. Now most of the people involved are gone or toned their crap down quite a bit. That's what happens to the Grinches of this world. And beleive me they end up sadder than the rest of us who are just trying to have a good time.
-- Posted by Shy Wreath on Sat, Dec 12, 2009, 11:44 pm EST

report this comment



"Anyone buy one?"

That sums up the "Spirit of Christmas."
-- Posted by Lives in Colorado on Sat, Dec 12, 2009, 11:31 pm EST

report this comment



It seems alot of people didn't get enough hugs or presents when they were kids. I miss Christmas concerts, going out caroling, going down downtown to see all the stores light up, Christmas trees in shops. The next thing to go in Rutland is the Tree lighting and the Christmas tree all together. It's sad, really!
-- Posted by Dwayne Johnson on Sat, Dec 12, 2009, 9:38 pm EST

report this comment



Dear Jim, I'll tell you what is happening to this country.....we have taken God out of many things, and now those politically correct imbeciles want to remove the very reason this country celebrates Christmas. Sad, sad, sad.
-- Posted by Hmm? What? on Sat, Dec 12, 2009, 9:18 pm EST

report this comment



We complain that Christmas has become too commercialized too much about gifts and not enough about the real meaning of Christmas. As a young man I always enjoyed Christmas. I enjoyed the whole family being together, the exchanging of gifts, going to school Christmas concerts, and seeing all the lit up houses and businesses. One of these traditions has been changed and it saddens me. I went to my daughters school to listen to her and the other children sing Holiday songs, or so I thought. No Christmas decorations, no mention of the season, and the songs these kids sung were not related to the holidays. They were indian songs and the like. I heard several comments from parents after the event and even two days later. Why would they take this very basic joy away from the parents and the children. Let then sing jingle bells, rudolph the reindeer or frosty the snowman. Who wants to hear their child on stage sounding like an indian during a Holiday Concert? You scrooges are pushing our kids to thinking that the only thing there is about Christmas is the presents. What is happening to this country?
-- Posted by Jim Eckhardt on Sat, Dec 12, 2009, 8:49 pm EST

report this comment



Gee, the USPS puts the kIbosh on Santa, the commercial symbol of Christmas, but continues to endorse the religious (and thus likely more offensive and controversial) symbols of the holiday by issuing stamps featuring various aspects of Christmas. According to a USPS news release "Millions of Americans celebrating Christmas this year can mail their holiday greetings bearing the image of a rare piece of art, now that the ****** Service has issued the Christmas: Madonna and Sleeping Child by Sassoferrato stamp."

In yet another fitting example of the politically correct, arbitrary and capricious nature of our government leaders and institutions, RUTLAND HAS BEEN SCROOGED AGAIN!

BAH HUMBUG TO YOU FROM YOUR UNITED STATES ****** SERVICE AND ITS RUTLAND POSTMASTER!
-- Posted by Bill O. Rights on Sat, Dec 12, 2009, 5:04 pm EST

report this comment



"I hate to dampen anyone's spirit" Why do I hear a ring of insincerity in that statement? Oh well I hope that everyone has a Merry Christmas or a Happy Holiday or whatever. Try to accept the spirit of the season even if everyone is not totally on board.
-- Posted by northstar62 on Sat, Dec 12, 2009, 1:50 pm EST

report this comment



Ahhhhh Christmas, that wonderful time of year. Straighten me out on one thing though. Christmas literally means Christ Mass, right? Its a christian celebration of the birth of their messiah. Wait, I thought a Mass was for the dead. Whatever. Now there's this Santa Claus thing too. The fat guy in a red suit delivering gifts down your chimney for no reason whatsoever but he's a great guy. I never got the connection. I think the South Park episode where Jesus and Santa have a fist fight to see who's real sums it all up.
I'd hate to dampen anyone's spirit at this joyous time of year. But, don't cha think this whole Xmass thing is just a way to give the economy a shot in the arm once a year? To keep the money flowing, the people buying, the stores busy. The spirit of giving should be a year round kinda thing. Why make up some crazy story just to get people to consume once a year?
Let the guy wear the suit. Who cares? My PO route driver wears a Santa hat.
She's kinda crazy. But, so what? That's what makes the world interesting.
Life is a circus, and some of us have a ringside seat to watch the faithful put on their show. The greatest show on earth.
Can I get some more popcorn?
-- Posted by Dr. Gonzo on Sat, Dec 12, 2009, 1:32 pm EST

report this comment



Ha, ha, ha. The RH used the word "p o s t a l" in the article but it removed it from my reply.
-- Posted by Michael in Vermont on Sat, Dec 12, 2009, 10:57 am EST

report this comment



"Aside from being recognizable and reassuring, official ****** uniforms are constructed to be visible with reflective material which promotes the letter carrier's personal safety in a variety of weather, lighting and road conditions."

So, mail carriers wear drab grey uniforms for their own safety. That's interesting. I was a mail carrier one Summer. Because I was a temp, I wasn't issued a uniform - I worn my own street clothes. I guess the post office wasn't interesting in the safety of their temporary mail carriers.
-- Posted by Michael in Vermont on Sat, Dec 12, 2009, 10:55 am EST

report this comment



Ahhhh i get it now..its simply REGULATIONS. Even though that particular Regulation wasn't enforced for 10 years until some anal whine-arse complained... and even though my mailman frequently brings packages to my door un-uniformed when they dont fit in the box. God knows its a matter of safety to require a uniform on a walking route in an crowded urban area, but only a 6 inch sticker on a car in a quiet rural one.

Trust the guy in the approved uniform kids, its just regulations that your next shower will contain zyklon-b.
-- Posted by None None on Sat, Dec 12, 2009, 10:45 am EST

report this comment



This has NOTHING to do with political correctness..it's about safety.

.
-- Posted by NONENONE ONE on Sat, Dec 12, 2009, 10:09 am EST

report this comment



LOL, some of you truly are hopeless. Common sense and reason are totally wasted on the typical Rutlander. Nobody's saying he can't dress up as Santa on his own time or even drive around blaring obnoxious xmas music from his stupid decorated tour bus. Just that he can't do it on company time. The man agreed to a certain set of rules when he was hired. I'm sure if he had asked at the interview if he could play dress up at work and was told no. he still would have taken the job. He is NOT a victim. And neither are any of you. Get over it.
-- Posted by the truth on Sat, Dec 12, 2009, 10:01 am EST

report this comment



Does anyone have a copy of the POLITICAL CORRECTNESS Book?

Who make sup this garbage? What has happen to the SPIRIT of things? Are we all suppose to be proper cold little puppets?
Good God, look at what we ware allowing ourselves to become.

I remember the fun as a young man riding to Rutland and lookingat all of the Christmas decorations. I remember the Christmas spirit all over the streets as you shopped and how people would smile and sincerely wish you a MERRY CHRISTMAS. The stores were all decorated and invited you into the atmosphere to shop and enjoy the spirit of the season. There were chuch choirs singing the carols and people on the streets singing. The lights on the poles added to the mood and as young man, I had a great spirit.
Now,there is so much Bah Humbug and people are afraid to be happy and others want people to stay miserable, for whatever reason.

Forget it, I prefer the Spirit. Heven forbid a Santa outfit, might make someone feel good and spreads some spirit around, quick, grab a rope and string the man up, for he is suppose to wear his uniform, read his book and bow to his leaders.

Merry Christmas and time to take back America and all that she once was, she can be again.
-- Posted by Name Change on Sat, Dec 12, 2009, 9:55 am EST

report this comment



Hey Does it Matter None, you're complaing about kids being allowed to "wear hats in school" while arguing that someone who is required by a CONTRACT HE AGREED TO FOLLOW WHEN HIRED ahouldn't have to wear his uniform because it's xmas? Wow ... hypocrite much?
-- Posted by the truth on Sat, Dec 12, 2009, 9:52 am EST

report this comment



Rural carriers deliver mail from the inside of marked U.S. Mail vehicles, hence they are not required under their contract to wear the uniform. That's the difference.
-- Posted by the truth on Sat, Dec 12, 2009, 9:44 am EST

report this comment



"Newsflash, morons ... the ****** uniform and the requirement to wear it while working as a mailman has been around for a couple of hundred years."

Bullshiet. Ive had my mail delivered to the same mailbox by Rural carriers for 40 years and have rarely seen one in a USPS uniform.

Ill wager you stop a Rural carrier in about ANY Vermont town and you will rarely see a usps uniform.

This guy wore the Santa suit in season for 10 years..until some little nazi wannabe complained.
-- Posted by None None on Sat, Dec 12, 2009, 9:38 am EST

report this comment



Kelly has dlivered our mail for years. You cant recognize him.. Come on people.. Yes I have children and I understand the whole thing of stranges.. Kelly has his mail carrier bag and ID... The problem is that KNOW ONE HAS Christmas Spirit!. Welcome to 2010. It just shows how far from values we have become and how politics have torn down our United States. The kids only do the Pledge one day a week and they dont even have to stand.. They can wear hats in school and disrespect our teachers.. Just another example of how TIMES HAVE CHANGED... So much for the good old days. What will it be like in another 10 years.. Not Christmas Ornaments in stores. It will be illegal to play christmas music on the radio.. or to sing the National Anthem at a Sport event! MERRY CHRISTMAS!!!
-- Posted by Does it Matter None on Sat, Dec 12, 2009, 9:35 am EST

report this comment



none none one - Did you happen to read the third paragraph of my post? i agreed with you that someone on official business with a uniform regulation should be wearing the prescribed uniform. If he wants to play santa at the mall or at the post office Christmas party that's fine. Oops I guess the post office won't be having a Christmas party, Well maybe a druid winter party then.
-- Posted by northstar62 on Sat, Dec 12, 2009, 9:32 am EST

report this comment



Seriously? The Herald just censored the word "p o s t a l". Maybe we should be more worried about that kind of ridiculous censorship tha we are about some poor clown being forced to do his job.
-- Posted by the truth on Sat, Dec 12, 2009, 9:29 am EST

report this comment



Newsflash, morons ... the ****** uniform and the requirement to wear it while working as a mailman has been around for a couple of hundred years. Which is before even Socia was hired. He knew about the rules. So does everyone else who is hired by the USPS or any other company who requires a uniform. If you have a problem with it, don't take the job. It's that simple. A work uniform is hardly an evil conspiracy against personal liberty, Vermontis ... I'm fairly confident even you know that much ... so quit acting like it is.
-- Posted by the truth on Sat, Dec 12, 2009, 9:27 am EST

report this comment



So what If I dress as a mail man carrying a mail bag going around pretending to get your mail for identity theft purpose? Or to rob you in a mail man suit? I don't buy that theory at all. You should be ashamed of your selves for doing that to somebody who has done it for years. And the people who complained about it should be ashamed of themselves, Santa Clause is a universal figure no matter what religion you celebrate. Santa Clause is not religion based!
We need more people like Kelly Socia in this town not just for the holidays but his spirit all year long. FREAKIN SCROOGE!
-- Posted by Dwayne Johnson on Sat, Dec 12, 2009, 9:19 am EST

report this comment



What a Grey, Dreary world is just over the hill.Uniformity enforced by law. Careful what you say, write or think.

Tolerate only those that fit in the group.The rest can go away. The same ideas and attitudes expressed here ended with people being gassed and cremated in the mid 20th century.
-- Posted by None None on Sat, Dec 12, 2009, 9:18 am EST

report this comment



It's a uniform issue, plain and simple. Socia shouldn't dress as Santa Claus, The Easter Bunny, Harry Potter, Jesus, or any of the other ridiculous non-existent things children (and far too many adults) believe are real. He is a mailman. That is what's real. That is what he is, no matter how above it he feels he is. If he doesn't like wearing the same uniform as everyone else, he can leave and try to pull his whiny, look at me crap at UPS and see how long he lasts or try to live off his Backdoor Tours business. Which reminds me, he shouldn't be wearing a jacket advertising his business while he's delivering mail either ... but they let him. You don't see him crying about that. What a clown.
-- Posted by the truth on Sat, Dec 12, 2009, 9:01 am EST

report this comment



Thinking of printing t-shirts that say"Beware, Politically Incorrect" Anyone buy one?
-- Posted by Colleen Wright on Sat, Dec 12, 2009, 8:37 am EST

report this comment



Sad. Oh well, I'd rather be right than politically correct any day.
-- Posted by Joe Kerswile on Sat, Dec 12, 2009, 8:32 am EST

report this comment



northstar62,

Sad life? Hardly, actually I have a good life and yes my children believe in Santa. I just don't think a mailman getting close to my house and my young children should be wearing a Santa suit.

What's to stop a child molester, robber or murderer capitalizing on this and wearing a Santa suit, caring some mail and doing God knows what? My children and their safety comes first.
.
-- Posted by NONENONE ONE on Sat, Dec 12, 2009, 7:43 am EST

report this comment



None none, What a sad life you must have. Life is filled with reality and a lot of that reality is not particularly positive. Santa is a bit of frivolity that most of us throughout the world of many many cultures have adopted. It makes kids happy with anticipation and parents happy to please their kids. It harms no one. When approached correctly it helps parents teach kids a little about giving to those less fortunate among us and joy of providing a little cheer to others. Kids outgrow the idea of a Santa soon enough but hopefully retain the lessons of giving for a lifetime.

If you don't believe in the nativity of Christ that is your business. There are many cultures who retain the idea of a Santa or Father Christmas etc that are not Christian. Everyone has their own religious background or none at all but it takes a real scrooge to be the one to try and ruin someone else's beleif for no good reason.

However I guess I have to agree that if there is a uniform for USPO employees they must abide by it unless they have special permission. The supervisors are under no obligation to give a reason to enforce a regulation unless they are being arbitrary in their enforcement. I would not be comfortable seeing a cop directing traffic in a santa suit.

Have a very Merry Christmas and a more tolerant new year.
-- Posted by northstar62 on Sat, Dec 12, 2009, 7:34 am EST

report this comment



Also...if you don't want to wear the uniform of the job then quit...Rutland has the highest unemployment in the State and there are plenty of hard working people who would love that job.
.
-- Posted by NONENONE ONE on Sat, Dec 12, 2009, 7:24 am EST

report this comment



I agree with the postmaster and some other people.

What's next, a Police Officer wearing a leprechaun suit on St. Patrick's Day?

Smarten up people.
.
-- Posted by NONENONE ONE on Sat, Dec 12, 2009, 7:22 am EST

report this comment



I would love to have None None's mailing address so I can mail him a year's worth of coal.
-- Posted by Ray Lemire on Sat, Dec 12, 2009, 7:18 am EST

report this comment



One could also look at it as protecting their child from a religious cult that worships a guy in a red suit on a day they claim their god was born, yet wasn't. Christmas has nothing to do with christ, has nothing to do with anything except old roman and pagan holidays. Christmas is a marketing tool developed to suck the weak minded "god fearing" in and get money from them...It also guilt's the rest of us into participating in this load of crap.
-- Posted by None None on Sat, Dec 12, 2009, 7:06 am EST

report this comment



Who cares!!! Political Correctness is out of control! This is the biggest pile of BS...
-- Posted by Russell Goodrich on Sat, Dec 12, 2009, 6:58 am EST

report this comment



These people who complain about Christmas decorations, Santa Claus and Nativity scenes sure don't turn down the holiday bonuses or the holiday off given by employers, now do they? Otherwise, those in schools who don't choose to celebrate Christmas would be at work during the Christmas break.

I am all for people celebrating events within their faith. But those fools who deny children the opportunity to make construction paper reindeer horns, or milk jug Santas are ripping off the kids fun. There are a few fools around who do this, and they are in the minority, but they have the biggest mouths and work hard to quash fun. The only way to get them to stop is TO tell them that we won't stand for it. That we want Christmas concerts and snowmen and Rudolph and all of the wonderful things that this season brings for kids. Their lives must be hideous with no joy or fun. And, you can bet that they won't have the courage to sign their own names in reply to this. So Merry Christmas Kelly, and all the other people who love the Christmas season for every reason. Thanks for making this part of the year so much fun for all of us-
-- Posted by Colleen Wright on Sat, Dec 12, 2009, 6:39 am EST

report this comment


You must be logged in to leave a comment. Register | Log In

Logout