• Going for the sure thing
    August 23,2012
     
    The Facebook fiasco brought me back to childhood, when I got my first lessons in the stock market.

    My father was a Jewish working-class investor, with sugar plum fortunes dancing in his head. Unfortunately, that’s where they would remain for most of his life.

    But when I was 9, I remember him touting a “sure thing” — United Park Mining.

    “That stock is going places,” he said of the Utah company, selling for about $1.67 a share. “It will go to 5 by the end of the year.”

    That year was 1958, and I envisioned us welcoming the New Year with champagne toasts to Guy Lombardo rather than the grape juice I was allowed at that age.

    “You think it’ll go up that much?” I asked.

    “Good as gold,” my father said of the mining company.

    My brother Malvey, then 16, was a believer. He had purchased 50 shares on his own from money saved from his earlier days as a newspaper delivery boy.

    This could be the beginning of the Elkin Empire; I thought of how I would be the envy of my fellow fourth graders.

    I did my math quickly: At 50 cents a week for allowance, my options were limited. It would be 1960 before I could compete with my brother.

    But he saw my interest, and ever the entrepreneur, he came up with a deal. “I’ll sell you one share at $1.67,” which I would have, given how much I had already saved, if my father would advance me a week’s allowance.

    “But ...”

    There’s always a “but” with big brothers.

    “I’ll be charging you one-eighth percent sales commission, which is what the brokers do — just to make it official, of course.”

    Of course.

    I couldn’t do the trade fast enough. What happened if UPM — I was an expert by then — went up to $2 the next day? I’d be out of luck — and a prosperous future.

    I got the advance from my father, dumped the coins in my brother’s lap the next day — including the commission — and asked for my stock certificate. (This was a time when they actually issued certificates of sale.)

    “I’ll write you out one, but to get a real certificate you have to buy more than one share — like me,” Malvey boasted.

    He wrote it out on loose-leaf paper from his school book, signed the “certificate,” and my father witnessed it.

    “Deal,” Malvey said, extending his hand.

    I shook it, anticipating the fortunes that awaited me.

    Let’s see, in a month, I could buy another share; better yet, in two weeks, maybe I could buy half a share from my brother — if it wasn’t 5 by then. Or maybe I could get a bigger advance from my father and then buy two shares and —

    And then United Park Mining, my golden buy, started going down.

    It dropped to $1.50, then, three days later, to $1.37, then, the end off the week — $1.25.

    I knew what I had to do.

    “I want my money back,” I demanded of my brother.

    “It doesn’t work like that,” he informed me for the first time.

    “I’ll go tell Pop,” I threatened.

    “Don’t bother him; he’s upset over how much he’s lost himself.”

    “But it was a sure thing.”

    “There’s no such thing as a sure thing,” said Malvey with something of a too satisfied smile.

    It was the first lesson I got in the market if not in life. “You got greedy,” he said, still smiling.

    Who was he? The anti-Gekko of the ’50s? (It would be six years before I “gambled” with him again, this time with $3 — I had a bigger allowance; surely, Liston pummeling Clay was a no-brainer.)

    I sold UPM the next week at a loss; I couldn’t take the pressure. By then, it was at $1.

    Malvey slowly counted out the coins. “Wait, it’s only 88 cents you gave me!”

    “You forgot the commission,” he said.

    Was it a lesson I would never forget? Of course not: Hello, 1987; goodbye to dreams, 2008.

    And then — surely, Facebook was a sure thing.

    I bought, I bit — I screamed.

    As the stock tanked, I knew what I had to do.

    “I want my money back,” I told my broker.

    He laughed.

    And you know, United Park Mining never hit 5 either.



    Michael Elkin is a writer living in Philadelphia.
    2 Comments
    MORE IN Election Letters
    Whether one thinks the demiscandals being howled about in Washington should or should not... Full Story
    In 1925, the year “The Great Gatsby” was published, the top 1 percent of Americans... Full Story
    Let’s try to come up with some positive thoughts about the recent political fortunes of the Obama... Full Story
    More Articles