Columnist off base on climate
John McClaughry’s June 13 article, ‘‘Gut check on ‘climate change,’” is a preposterous, disingenuous mixture of red herrings and tortured metaphor. First, he says that the concept of global warming was renamed global climate change because the warming “failed to appear.” That’s dead false on two counts. First, the warming has appeared, and the global temperature anomaly curve that McClaughry himself refers to shows a huge upswing since about 1976. Second, the new name for the phenomenon is actually more accurate. In addition to temperature, climate includes patterns of precipitation, humidity, wind and seasons. Global warming, which is an easily verifiable fact, causes climate change, both globally and locally.
The next part of McClaughry’s article states that governments should not take a role in responding to climate change. I guess he doesn’t think that government should try to protect social stability or the economic interests of the people, and he’s entitled to his opinion. Personally, I think that weather extremes such as drought and floods are a problem, not just for life in general but for people’s livelihoods in particular. Worldwide precipitation data show that the extreme rainstorms of each year are becoming much more extreme. This is no scare story. It’s simply a fact.
As to McClaughry’s bizarre metaphors that compare climate scientists to theologians and scientific fact to goblins, it would be comic genius if it weren’t sincere. Ninety-eight percent of climate scientists agree that the extreme changes we see in the past several decades are caused by human activity. That’s called scientific consensus. Unfortunately, climate change denial (a syndrome largely confined to the United States) doesn’t just affect the deniers, but everyone. We must, as individuals, communities and governments, take action now to prevent further catastrophic changes that have already harmed, and will continue to harm, our ecosystems, our economy and our stability.
RutlandMORE IN Letters
- Most Popular
- Most Emailed
- RICHARD'S POOR ALMANACK: On this day in 1618, English author, poet, soldier, adventurer Sir Walter Raleigh is beheaded for conspiring to overthrow King James I, but more likely to mollify offenses to Spain. His executioner has to implore him for silence.
- RICHARD'S POOR ALMANACK: On this day in 1492, Italian explorer, admiral of the ocean sea, Christopher Columbus, sailing for the Spanish crown, 'discovers' Cuba; on this day in 1964, U.S. officials deny American involvement in bombing North Vietnam.
- Video: Fire engulfs house on Pine Street
- RICHARD'S POOR ALMANACK: On this day in 1936, Mrs. Wallis Warfield Spencer Simpson, mistress of King Edward VIII, is granted her second divorce, enabling her to marry the king. The government, the Church of England and the London Times have another idea.
- RICHARD'S POOR ALMANACK: V-2 No. 13, launched this day in 1946 from White Sands, New Mexico, takes first photographs of Earth from the edge of the planet's outer atmosphere; 1947: Walt Disney testifies before HUAC, names employees he says are communists.
- TOMORROW'S HEADLINES TODAY: Vermont's brand discussed at Killington, state's attorney candidates Marc Brierre and Rose Kennedy profiled, Curtis reports about Rutland police chief's new job, and four arrested, charged for heroin, crack sales.