The commentary in the Rutland Herald by Trevor MacKay and Maya Sobel (April 9) shows courage and talent. It is a well-written piece that deserves credit for what it does. However, their premise is wrong.

The Black Lives Matter movement is not political. It is a social movement that has the intent of correcting one of the worst social ills in the history of this country because it affirms that we are all important — including people of color. The flag does not express an opinion but rather, a fact that should guide our every action as a country.

The Black Lives Matter flag is a statement of just how far we still (have) to go in order to ensure equity and justice for all people. It addresses a shameful history that is replete with racial discrimination and hatred, and that still exists today.

No longer can we tolerate people of color being treated unfairly in the law, in housing, education and jobs. No longer can we tolerate the fact that people of color live with a vigilance that is engendered by the fear that they may not be treated fairly, that they may experience violence, death or imprisonment without justice.

Distrust and anxiety caused by explicit and implicit racism is expressed in actions by individuals and our institutions, often without acknowledgment of the mainstream white citizens of our country. There is a rift between people that needs to be healed. It is an illness that affects the soul of American society.

Every one of us loses out when even one person is left out of opportunities or loses their life without justice. History shows us that this is especially true in the community of people of color.

The students worry that their right to critically think and express themselves is threatened by the flying of the BLM flag. The very fact that they have written this commentary demonstrates that this is false. In fact, the flying of the flag has already generated discourse and critical thinking in the schools and in the community.

Flying the flag is a statement of respect and tolerance that is socially constructed because it shows that we are a community that welcomes and celebrates people of color at a time when so many places fail to offer a safe haven.

The students should embrace the potential to debate and research the history of race. They would come to understand that the very notion of race is a social construct, that racism is a social disease and that the best way to change that is through social discourse and heart-to-heart conversations.

Dr. Alis Headlam is a member of the NAACP, a former member of the Multiracial Alliance of the Rutland Area and a former professor in teacher training.

You must be logged in to react.
Click any reaction to login.

(3) comments


It is Policical this is a violent anti-law and order organization that has called for the killing of police and has exhibited an outright racist hatred of white people...


I'm sorry you are failing to see that systematic racism is still present in our society and despite people of color now being the majority, we are still treated differently and not equally compared to our Caucasian counterparts.


Hello Axiom,
Rutland High School or any other high school shouldn't get involved in any political movements and that's just what this is and nothing less and you must be blind to the facts.
I believe all lives matter but when an officer of the law says "Stop it's the police freeze put your weapon down" that's what they mean skin color doesn't matter that officers life matter he is doing his job how can we make a political movement out of someone doing their job should they all be shot dead in the line of duty look at the stats more whites get shot than blacks so if you can tell me or explain to me how this even remotely come close to systematic racism should our policeman be shot dead in the line of duty because the person isn't compliant and pointing a weapon at an law enforcement officer it becomes a situation of shoot or be shot maybe you should become a law enforcement officer and get a better understanding of what's going on in the real world instead of a political columnist.

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.